Comments

Creepypasta costumes require alot of DIY. 

Latex, Blood, Makeup can all be ordered on amazon for fastest shipping <3

I would recommend using Closet pieces for the costumes as opposed to ordering clothes online. 
Any Super Center should have a hoodie and skinny jeans you can grab. 

Don't be afraid to compromise on things, Nina is going to be the hardest one- so feel free to maker her your own and lean into head cannons.

Overall, just have fun! My laughing jack costume isnt too accurate but people still love it. 

If you need help with makeup feel free to DM me I'm really good with SFX Stuffs :3

Aaaa ik exactly what u meann!! Me and my friends were gonna do the same buuut the only creepypasta costumes being sold for generally affordable prices that we found are on amazon and aliexpress and stuff and the downside to that is that most of them r 100% polyester and don't look the best, if you dont mind that then u can check on there. If not, you can get them custom made (although probably much more expensive and likely not gonna come before halloween atp), or what i find a lot of people do is try to find stuff similar to their outfits at thrift stores and DIY the fit!! Sorry if i wasnt much help but yeah :p