I've been thinking, and we've survived thousands of years without AI (in the sense it's used today), yet some people now "need" it to go about their day. Why?
Why strip your life of what makes it worth living? What are you going to do when AI does everything for you? Lay down and die?
A common excuse to use AI is because it saves time, sure it does, but with that time you probably want to/are expected to do something else. Imagine changing your activity to something else, but AI can do that for you as well, so you change your activity again, and could you believe it, AI does that as well, and it just keeps going. What's the point?
Makes me think of a classic Swedish TV series called "Lycka till", at least in that one they finally realised that streamlining everything comes with it's disadvantages, and what was originally meant to just be an aid to a human, quickly completely replaces it.
In a world with billions of people, why do we need machines to do the things people can do? And if we make machines do everything we can do, what are we expected to do instead?
Comments
Displaying 12 of 12 comments ( View all | Add Comment )
larpmaster5222
Yes, I do. Come and take it. I do not think wasting hundreds of hours reading shitty documentation rather than simply generating examples is what makes life worth living, quite the opposite actually.
I understand your point, but to me it sounds like you're the wrong person to be spending hundreds of hours reading. If you hate it so much, why did you sign up for it in the first place? Leave it to a person who wants to do it and who understands the purpose of deeper knowledge.
If you want a machine to tell you everything I can't stop you, but personally I prefer to stay curious and find things out on my own.
The point of this post was me asking why AI should takeover and do things some people actually WANT to do. I was not asking why people who hate their jobs use it, because I already get that.
by リン5; ; Report
I am a hobbyist. I do enjoy programming (sometimes) but I also do it because nobody else wants to build stuff that meets my needs. Doing that goes much faster when I can have AI write new docs for me instead of spending forever trying to read the official 10-year-outdated Doxygen site written by a guy who barely knows English. AI is also immensely useful for debug/troubleshooting and code checks, whether it's on code it wrote itself or mine. And I don't exactly think I'm missing out on much if I let it deal with the tedious boilerplate parts of programming so I can get to the actually important shit.
by larpmaster5222; ; Report
If you're confident you already know how to do everything it helps you with, and you think it's a waste of time checking it manually, so be it. But some people don't, and I think it's worrying that so many people these days seem to need help with basic things... And imagine when your help starts doing everything for you, even the things you enjoy doing on your own.
Like I said earlier I appreciate doing things even if I know a machine can do them for me. That's what brings purpose to my life, but I guess everyone is different.
by リン5; ; Report
Yeah well I do enjoy programming but again, I mainly do it to get shit done. And I'm a hobbyist because I want to get shit done on my own terms. I'm not here for some ego boost. If there's a machine that lets me not spend 6 hours in one gdb session, then by God I am going to use that machine so I can get back to the parts that are less similar to self harm.
It seems to me that you don't really do any development outside of website stuff. And that's OK. But LLMs in programming can't really be compared to how AI generally is used in the arts because even though artists really love pretending otherwise, programming is not an art. There's a lot more nuance to how LLMs can be leveraged in a programming workflow than "vibe code absolutely everything" and "no AI ever for any reason at all". If you use it like an idiot, then yes, you are wasting your money and making more work for yourself. But when you put it to proper use with actual oversight, it can be a massive productivity boost (ESPECIALLY for small teams, which does apply here).
by larpmaster5222; (edited); Report
You've made your point clear that you prefer using it and I don't think we'll ever get to a full agreement here. I'm not denying that it's useful, but maybe that's why it sometimes entails danger. I think we're essentially on the same side, considering you also seem to realise the problems with it becoming a need to people, or like you say, those using it like an idiot.
by リン5; (edited); Report
Mutant
(edited)
Report
I feel the same way about smartphones honestly. People get used to these kind of things to quickly
lulu.mp3
100% agree! We were fine without it before, so we don't need it now, especially when there are more cons than pros to it existing in its current form. There actually was a study done recently that suggests that people who rely heavily on AI actually become stupider! That's enough of a reason for me to never depend on it X_X
I can definitely see people becoming stupider when relying on AI too much. When I went to university we weren't allowed to use calculators in our math classes, because they wanted to see that we were able to make the calculations on our own and I know that when you're very used to using a calculator you struggle more to do even the simplest of calculations. I'm guessing the same applies when you get used to using AI.
by リン5; ; Report
I never thought of it like that, but honestly, I see the connection!
by lulu.mp3; ; Report
flowersnbullets [them]
Some people laugh when I say I prefer handmade or artisanal memes, but it's related to what you argue here. A bunch of companies are working so that ai can take over not just our jobs, but our creativity and intelligence. It's beyond messed up that we're expected to get worked to death in menial jobs and still give these companies money!
Yeah, if we're supposed to continue working like we are today there's not gonna be much left for us to do... There are still fields where manual labour is still required, but if they could I'm sure these companies would love to make a change to that.
The question is who will pay for the services when more and more people lose their jobs.
by リン5; ; Report