Home» Forum» Books & Writing» Good Characters Bad Plot or Good Plot Bad Characters?

Good Characters Bad Plot or Good Plot Bad Characters?

Back to Books & Writing

Would you excuse unsalvageable plot holes if the characters are lovable, or would you excuse horribly-written characters if the plot is intriguing? 

This is a question I've been thinking about for a while, and I wanted to see what other people's perspectives are on it. I understand it's an extreme and rather vague scenario, but it's fun to think about :P

Because, personally, I can't tolerate poorly written characters even if the plot was the most creative, genius, mind-blowing piece of writing ever. I just can't. I find it hard to love the story or get invested, even when I can appreciate the world-building and effort put into the story.

Obviously in an ideal scenario a story would have both good characters and a good plot, but in the event that one of those elements were missing, which one could you let go of? 

image-2024-05-24-113141642.png

stay swag☆

For me I prefer Good characters with bad plot. If I find characters appealing and interesting, I dont really mind the bad plot, since the characters made it enjoyable :D If plot is good but characters bad... I just cant enjoy the story if I find the character annoying or just anything really. 

‧₊ ᵎᵎ 🍒 ⋅ ˚✮

@PollyLuu Totally agree with this take!!! :) i feel the same way

@PollyLuu same here!! Glad I'm not crazy for preferring the character over the story lmao

stay swag☆

good characters with bad plot >>> i cannot stand bad characters, i will be putting a book down unfinished if there are bad characters

I want to believe

@batshybea SO REAL THO except unfortunately I kept reading because I don't like leaving books unfinished 💔 I was ragebaiting myself atp

stay swag☆

@MiRAGE_☆ nooo hahaha I have been there and done that on multiple occasions, it is a true torture </3 moving past the not wanting to leave a book unfinished was freeing but now it makes it hard to finish books i enjoy at times, so perhaps it was not for the best haha

I want to believe

Good characters bad plot in my opinion. It could be the most awful plot of all time but a good character can make it way more bearable. 

"Secret technique! Sprout Scattering!"

@GillFilmReviews21 exactly what I was thinking! Im glad a lot of people agree w me lmao

stay swag☆
This reply was deleted.

@Cernunnos that's an interesting perceptive on it! I see what you mean

stay swag☆

good characters with a bad plot is definitely easier to get through, tho I can go the other way if the plot is really good or makes me the right kinda interested and the characters aren't unbearable

Definetly good characters, in my opinion characters make or break the plot. With reading its nearly impossible to know what the story is about if the character is badly written, or atleast for me.... The characters ARE the plot. 

@Z1._.3A! This is my opinion, too. But it's also the reason I made this forum, I was curious to see if anyone thinks a plot can stand without its characters, like for example liking a movie because it has high action sequences but the characters have no personality

But so far almost everyone agrees that good characters can redeem any bad plot heh

stay swag☆

You must be logged in to reply.