Home» Forum» Art & Photography» Debate with me: at what point should we separate art from the artist and fiction from reality

Debate with me: at what point should we separate art from the artist and fiction from reality Pending

Back to Art & Photography

There’s been a lot of talk about controversial art/artist in spaces I’m in, I would like to know what other artist think about this.

Feel free to explain your stance to me, just note I might have questions. Also make it clear if you want to debate, I won’t do so without permission 

The biggest bird

i don't think covering controversial topics in art makes you a bad person. often it can be good, helping you put evils to rest and explore situations in a safe and controlled manner. this is more or less the case with all works of fiction.


what i am not qualified to speak about is engaging with said art. fiction CAN affect reality, it happens all the time, i'm tired of people who engage with problematic art saying it can't. however, engaging with fiction should not make you a bad person necessarily, it's often a matter of perception and external factors such as mental disorders. sometimes you can be a bad person while engaging with completely normal media. it really depends, which is why it's so volatile.


i mainly don't like people who enjoy problematic media shoving it in the faces of people without their consent, but what do i know.

that's what i think, anyway...

rei_2.gif track44.gif rei_1.gif

I feel like you can separate the art from the artist as long as you're not funding them. Like if you have pirated music or something fanmade that money isn't going to them so that's fine. If you're watching something they made or buying something directly from them then you're funding them so it doesn't apply.

 Perhaps badly phrased but i think you can only seperate the art from the artist if you're appreciation doesn't benefit them in anyway. 

Link click 💕

in terms of series like harry potter i believe giving the works any kind of attention benefits the author by proxy. it's best to substitute with other media or act like it doesn't exist

that's what i think, anyway...

rei_2.gif track44.gif rei_1.gif

You can always separate the art from the artist but fiction from reality is very different from art from the artists

I could argue with myself that if it in its nature is inherently bad then by that point you are unable to separate the art from the artist as the art thats been produced is in its essence wrong but we could also argue what is “wrong” and what isnt “wrong” 

If an artist made a song about depression or similar and that artist turns out to be a pedophile or an abuser the song has nothing wrong with it because we cannot tie two actions together (unless it has been stated) and at this point you can consume whatever the media is as long as its pirated (but in general most people would completely stop indulging all together)

Now fiction does affect reality but it doesn’t make the person bad for reading , listening or watching any source of media sometimes you are intrigued and you want to know more but afterwards you should remind yourself of morals and what is the basic “right” and “wrong” (depending on the severity of what you consumed)

My Signature
Adrianne lenkers no.1 fan even / the truth is out there

You must be logged in to reply.