Gotta go with mania. Easily my favorite 2D platformer ever. What it lacks in completely original level themes it more than makes up for in design, gimmicks, and visuals for those re used themes. I honestly think the mania versions of those levels are better than the originals in most cases, something like flying battery zone especially feels like a new level completely. And the 4 new zones, some of the absolute best in the series, studiopolis alone would have been an amazing standout, but we also got mirage saloon, press garden, and Titanic Monarch. All of these have such unique themes for the series, along with the amazing visuals that really bring the places to life. And the music for these levels my god, just go listen to them, and hell the whole soundtrack, because words can’t do it justice. It’s so rare to have a game that was obviously made by people who are huge fans, but isn’t designed just for fans. So many people I know who aren’t huge sonic fans have played and absolutely loved the game. While not the most original or groundbreaking, to me its the absolute best classic sonic gameplay can offer.