Did Carlisle really save the vampires he turned, or did he simply condemn them to an existence they never got to choose? It's an interesting question when we consider that, despite his good intentions, he gave other people a completely different life from the one they once knew. By turning them, Carlisle offered them the chance to keep existing, escape death, and even find a new family. But he also condemned them to live forever with a nature that demands sacrifices, self-control, and constant restraint. Maybe he saved their bodies, but did he really save their lives? After all, no matter how much Carlisle believed he was doing the right thing, turning someone into a vampire meant making a choice for them that could never be undone.
You must be logged in to reply.