Here's some of the things I have swapped out in an attempt to break myself out of the need to look at my phone. Now, these are for me, they might not be for everyone else, but it might give you some ideas.
FIRST OFF:

I put clocks up everywhere in my home, so I don't have to look at my phone as often. I'm also a little time-blind, so this helps me stay on track. Win-win.

Digital camera and an extra battery. Less chances of getting distracted by notifications. A little cumbersome, NGL.

Sure. It doesn't offer the variety that streaming does, but man, having no ads really makes up for that. Also, that thing is also huge, and has and expansion slot so you can have pretty much every song you want. Also a little cumbersome.

Okay, this one is a little more niche. I don't mind radio, and I don't mind local ads. I mainly just want background noise, and this keeps me from getting lost on Youtube, as well as cuts down on the choice fatigue/paralysis.

This is my newest acquisition: a non-smart alarm clock with 4 fully customizable alarms. Like most people, I use my phone as my alarm clock, so it has to be next to the bed (and within easy reach until the wee hours.) With this I can set my weird work schedule, charge my phone across the room, and not have to wake my partner up with a screaming alarm.

This is probably the most niche and unnecessary things I've ever done, but it's my favorite. That beautiful monstrosity is hooked up to my smartphone via bluetooth. Since the transmitter works best if the smartphone is close by, I have to leave my phone with my... phone. I leave the notifs volume up all the way so I can hear texts, but less scrolling! Definitely not perfect. I don't get a lot of calls.
COMING SOON: an analog watch with a calendar setting.
Have you made any analog swaps? What's working for you? Let us know!