So I started a brass quintet at my school. We were integrating a new member (2nd trumpet) and our first trumpet couldn't make it since she was sick.
My quintet has a really good dynamic, we're close friends, don't bicker seriously, have fun but still get our work done.
Context: A week ago we were talking to an upperclassman who has had a woodwind quintet for 4 years (their quintet had a very different dynamic from ours, when not actively playing, instead of joking around, they would be on their phones which says that they didn't have quite as much fun as my quintet does). I brought up having a social media page, since if I'm scrolling Tiktok and found a video of our dynamic, I would be intrigued/would think it's fun. The upperclassman told me it wasn't really worth it, since it wouldn't really reach the people we want to, and suggested having what we want to advertise ourselves with on the schools band pages. I agreed and said that's probably what we would do
Today, we were having a lot of fun at practice, so much so we honestly weren't getting much done, so I thought in the moment that a social media page would be really fun, so I make a Tiktok channel, and a video introducing the people in our quintet, just for fun
I sent it to the group chat, and our first trumpet player (who wasn't there) said, "What is the social media even for? We were originally planning to have it made around the time we play at [our first, upcoming gig]. Without any gigs, it's just a group of people goofy off, not a true representation of what we (I thought) wanted out of this group"
I get it was a genuine thought, but at the same time it made me feel really bad. Why? I don't really know. I think it's the way she worded it, in my brain, I see posting videos of us being silly is us showing our dynamic, maybe even something akin to a section media page. But is that too informal for a new quintet trying to get gigs just to share music with our community? Idk
Comments
Displaying 3 of 3 comments ( View all | Add Comment )
neomatcha
i get both of your povs. you wanna have fun w your friends like any high schooler, and she wants to advance musically/take it a bit more serious like any quintet player. she might be a little annoyed that she wasnt there to be in the video/be left out (。•́︿•̀。), and it's reasonable to want to focus on music playing.
at the same time, a couple minutes spent making a silly tiktok isn't gonna hurt anyone, and her wording was a bit rude :/
def talk to your group about what everyone wants out of it! hopefully, you can find a middle ground between locking in and being silly that keeps everyone happy. ^^ good luck!!
JulytoSeptember
Theres nothing wrong with posting silly videos, having a bit of fun. Being too serious and only seeing things in a one way path is just gonna make life so much less enjoyable. Its not because you havent played a gig yet that it makes you "just a group of people goofing off, it also doesnt take away from what your friend would like the band to be, two things can coexist at the same time. Keep the whimsy up.
Therenegadeklown
Don't let her get u down bro ur whimsy makes the world better trust 🔥🔥🔥