Home» Forum» General Discussion» Favourite/crush you had on creepypastas?

Favourite/crush you had on creepypastas?

Back to General Discussion
Listing 21-38 of 38   < Prev 1 2   Latest ↓

Really a kinda weird question, but any of you guys ever had a crush with a creepypasta? I remember mine was clockwork, and i dont even know why. Also had a crush on Masky.


hbu guys?

Just an online girl~
Replying to @真人 (post is on page 1): “@xX_aneixxita_Xx do you wanna take a wild guess”

@kawaiimahito I mean... I reaaaally wanna take a wild guess. Is that weird 4chan slenderman parody?

Just an online girl~

@xX_aneixxita_Xx i was not on 4chan so i'm not sure.

used to have the biggest crush on slenderman at 8 and it shaped me into who i am today cuz lowkey bc of him im super into mannequins   cuz when i was younger i thought he was one 

Definitely Jeff!

@xxxx[{::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::> ♡

When I was 8 I had the biggest and fattest crush on both Masky and Nina x~x

I Had a big crush on Dr. Smiley and clockwork when I was 10. But omg 7 year old me loved anime jeff the killer sm (ToT)

@Alexi Sparkles! (glmrklldUS!) OMG SAME!! came for anime Jeff, stayed for clockwork.

Just an online girl~

@xX_aneixxita_Xx 

twins 🥹!!

I kinda was into Jeff.... idk even why lol

omg this is bringing back memories to 10 year old me lol. i was SOOO big into creepypasta around 2018/2019. i even had one of those stupid instagram roleplay accounts.. i was judge angels tho so it's okay LOL XD 

to answer the question tho i was infatuaaateddd with EJ and splendorman. i dabbled in a bit of love for kagekao/nurse ann/candy pop but it was mainly EJ. and i still love creepypasta today!!!! long live the internet weirdness

@sapphic omg my back cracked, my knees popped and my kidney hurt cuz WYM 10 Y O IN 2018??!! I FEEL LIKE A MUSEUM RELIC OMG /sobs

But fr tho, I always wanted to make a roleplay acc on Instagram but never decided on which one I'd be cuz I was so in love with all the proxys. EJ is such a classic!

Just an online girl~

@xX_aneixxita_Xx LOOLL i'm just a youngin i promise... but no yeah it was definitely a lot of fun!!! i made a bunch of friends on there. it definitely expanded my creepypasta knowledge because my mutuals and i were all more 'niche' characters like judge angels, lyra, sadie, x virus, etc etc. such a wonderful community!!!!

i used to have a crush on eyeless jack n clockwork .. 

he / him

had a supes big thing for Jeff!! (gee i wonder how u all knew that) and also Tim and Brian from MH- and Habit from EMH

Replying to @Omnium (post is on page 1): “as a kid i had a self insert oc that i shipped with slenderman, and i made comics of her and him together in a journal. one day my 5th grade math teacher saw...”

i didn't have a crush on a creepypasta, but in my junior and senior year of high school, i simped for this gorgeous creature. i think that counts for something???

Oh God don't get me started ToT I was OBSESSED with Ticci Toby and Masky. Masky is still fine as hell tho I can't lie ((CANON MASKY. NOT FANON >:(())

ticci toby 4ever!! ive always loved him and ben, maybe cuz im so much like him LOL! my pfp is even me cosplaying him a while ago

Jeff the Killer has always been my favorite because, even though it's a bit "impossible," I love it; on the other hand and this one actually has a story that is more realistic (in very heavy quotation marks) there's Laughing Jack, hehehe.

Listing 21-38 of 38   < Prev 1 2   Latest ↓

You must be logged in to reply.