Home» Forum» General Discussion» General Discussion

General Discussion

Back to General Discussion

Julius Caesar, or George Meade?

Blackjack Pershing, or King Henry V?

A LOT of generals to talk about!

Who's your favorite?

Who was the best tactician?

Who was the best strategist?

Who was most inspiring? 

Or perhaps, who was weirdest. or most lucky, or dastardly?

Or whatever. 

I'll tell you what. When I was a las growing up in Virginia we were fed a bill of goods regarding Robert E. Lee. Despite the Daughter's of the Confederacy image campaign taken place nearly a century earlier- I was taught in school that he was a very smart general who wasn't a racist and just loved Virginia. He was indeed a slave owner and there are records of him beating slaves. There's more whitewashing that happened of Lee but I'm in grad school and don't have time to write a whole sang essay. His military prowess is up for some debate as well. Glad I don't have to feel sympathetic for this shithead any longer. 👍

If you want to know more about Lee's BS smarter folks than me have written about it. Sometimes it's called the "kindly general myth" or the "lost cause myth." 

~*: We'll see it through! :*~
1 reply

@tellmesecrets painfully aware of his myths. Speaking not of the man, but of the general, I think he was good but overrated. He was never the same general after losing Stonewall Jackson.

At Gettysburg, Meade, a second string lighthouse builder bested him when he was at his zenith. And I'll always think of Grant as amongst the first 'modern' general while Lee was one of the last 'old school' generals

NAPOLEON BONAPARTE. He had all the major European nations declare war against him personally. It's genuinely interesting how he went from being minor nobility to the emperor of france, to people even calling him the antichrist. And the guy was made brigadier general at the age of 24. I'm almost 24, I'm nowhere near leading an army over the Alps.

1 reply

@Upsilon I'd say he was more bold than brilliant. His hubris and the Russian winter caught up with him.

Never the less, he showed more results than most! 

Hello! I'm Lori's husband - she asked me if I had anything to contribute since I'm a historian and history teacher. And I always put in my two cents for Ulysses S Grant for a couple reasons. 

First off, as mentioned before, saying he's among the first 'modern' generals is absolutely correct - he's the future that nobody wanted to acknowledge. If you look at his strategy, you see the passing of eras - Lee (vastly overrated and mythologized, absolutely) was a master of a dying age of battlefield maneuver. I also hold that a lot of his success came from the fact that so many of his strategic situations were so dire they necessitated the unorthodox, which threw off opponents. Grant, however, understood the emerging industrial, total style of warfare on what I think was an instinctual level. 

He understood key lessons I impart to students: not to be mentally mired by failure, to be concerned with the immediate situation, instead of fixating on a theoretical future, and the determination to work despite adversity. 

In any event, to avoid going on too long, you can see the future and WWI coming in his late-war work around Petersburg and Richmond, which should have alarmed Europe's generals but they frequently treated the US as an outlier. 

I'd also be remiss as a Canadian if I didn't put in a good word for Arthur Currie, a business failure, embezzler, and wildly unlikely candidate for possibly the most effective general of WWI - a key reason  why the Canadian Corps were some of the best soldiers in the entire Allied arsenal.

Sorry for 'butting in', as it were, but she did ask me to, and hope you're all doing well!

1 reply

@Lori and even Arthur Currie echoes Grant in the manner of which he was uniquely bad at everything in life EXCEPT being a general! 

And yes, the US civil war presages WWI warfare in a number of areas including more rapid fire arms, naval warfare, more accurate artillery, how industrial might was put to use, trench warfare, and even submarine warfare. 

You'll have to forgive me, I don't have the WWII'Tism hyperfixation that my partner has, so my details are incredibly spotty 😆 But every now and then, he tells me about the Night Witches, Soviet women aviators who would perform tactical bombings in the middle of night by cutting the engines of their planes and gliding silently. I just think that's so neat ☺️

❝ Smartasses get killed. We always see to that. ❞ — The Legion
img_6a6e0863c56fb6.61796251.webpimg_6a6e0863c61cb7.12502203.webpimg_6a6e0863e01c83.17200934.webpimg_6a6e0863e02989.31410830.webp
4 replies

@𝘼𝙨𝙝𝙚𝙧 well, that's a bit off topic, but YAAASSS! 

@Cranky Old Witch 😅 my bad, i don't really know all that much about these things, i just saw some people talking about various strategists and whatnot and that's all my brain's got, hah

❝ Smartasses get killed. We always see to that. ❞ — The Legion
img_6a6e0863c56fb6.61796251.webpimg_6a6e0863c61cb7.12502203.webpimg_6a6e0863e01c83.17200934.webpimg_6a6e0863e02989.31410830.webp

@𝘼𝙨𝙝𝙚𝙧 it's a general discussion. We're talking about generals! 🥰 

For a discussion on the Soviet night witches, maybe you want to start a Pilot Program! I might even jump in with the Tuskegee airmen, or the Doolittle raid! 😊

@Cranky Old Witch . Ah. That's right. General has multiple meanings, doesn't it. Not. Just. Generality. Riiiiight. Got it 👍

❝ Smartasses get killed. We always see to that. ❞ — The Legion
img_6a6e0863c56fb6.61796251.webpimg_6a6e0863c61cb7.12502203.webpimg_6a6e0863e01c83.17200934.webpimg_6a6e0863e02989.31410830.webp

You must be logged in to reply.