Do you support the trend of cross-media adaptation in works of art (Examples: novels into animation; animation into live-action; books into television series; films into musicals; etc.)
why? or why not?

Do you support the trend of cross-media adaptation in works of art (Examples: novels into animation; animation into live-action; books into television series; films into musicals; etc.)
why? or why not?

sometimes its SO GOOD but sometimes its awful.. Like movie to musical is AWFUL sometimes.. but besides that i think book to movie might be my fav nd almost always good ![]()
it depends on how they adapt it
I like when they get real weird with it. Short story into experimental song. Song into Novella. Here's the song from that particular bit:
There are tons of examples of graphic novels being successfully made into movies and television. So many anime productions are so true to their manga source material that you can pick them up and read where the show left off. I think it's tougher with books though. Books rarely have a visual language that's cohesive enough that filmmakers can draw upon it without disappointing readers. Also, books have the ability to tell the audience about things that are happening behind the scenes, whereas good screenwriting requires showing the story through action rather than using exposition.
It wholely depends. I'm quite excited for the V/H/S SCP adaptation for example but I've seen some absolute stinkers haha.
hoo boy,聽
I DESPISE ITTTTT!! or, rather, i cannot stand when what happens is that they strip down an established storyline to "chase mainstream appeal" which... feels like most adaptations ive seen...
im not too picky tho, if done right i'm fine with it, if it's bad i just don't engage.
i just feel like cheap cash grabs ruin the medium.
i'd far prefer to see side stories set in the same universe as the original work and different characters, possibly working behind the scenes of the main cast, over reworking a perfectly fine narrative.
Absolutely love it. If it's bad you can just ignore it so it's never an issue. I also watch quite a bit of Anime so it would be very odd of me to complain when most of it comes from manga. Live actions i usually hate tho, they're so tragic 馃挃聽
I support the concept! I don't always support the outcomes. Lanterns is a sore spot for me at the minute as I feel it is an extremely poor adaptation of Green Lantern comic mythos. But a lot of good adaptations have been made of course, I think Matilda as a book, as a film, and as a musical is wonderful for an example. Anime based on manga is also adaptation and I think there are so many good animes based on manga.
The other thing that can be annoying (especially with superhero stuff) is that it can be incredibly hard to avoid adaptations you don't like in fandom. Again, with Lanterns, all of the GL stuff I've seen recently has been about the show instead of the comics and because they're so different it's annoying to see stuff that is out of character or comic inaccurate in comic spaces because people are acting like they know all about it just because they've seen the show.
I did not realise I had so many feelings on this topic until now. 馃槄
Because I鈥檓 an anime lover, I guess that means I鈥檓 all for this concept. I also think turning media into different formats so it can reach different groups of people is a wonderful thing. So maybe there鈥檚 just a bit of a grey area here, like there is with so many other things?

I wrote an entire blogpost on this awhile back! It's a revamp of an actual paper/essay I wrote years ago but I think it's still relevant.
Super depends!
For example I think the PJO tv show is shit bc its played way more seriously than the books bc we don't have Percy's inner dialogue.聽
The musical is way better for this exact reason, musicals are allowed to be silly and goofly while dealing with tough shit!聽
SO it all depends on what the original medium needs for the adaptation to work.
it can be. I love the DOaWK movies, but ig that's an exception lol
You must be logged in to reply.