Fargo, I kept hearing how it was a masterpiece but when I finally saw it, I couldn't stand any of the characters. I understand that it's social commentary and that's why the characters are basically retarded but I think there are better ways to present the same critiques.
It's a Wonderful Life, the most predictable movie ever, also terrible structure, we keep seeing George getting fucker over and over and over and over and on and on too many times. People who like this film can't seem to stand when someone criticizes it.
The Blair Witch Project, it's one of those movies that's aged very poorly and it's mostly because it relied on it's viral marketing that would only work in 1999 when people were more gullible but these days the plot is laughably bad, "watch out, guys! Someone tied a bunch of sticks together", "why did you throw the map? I don't know, I just did. I must have been possessed or something". Most people are finally seeing this film for the garbage that it really is but it still has plenty of defenders.
Maybe MySpace was all the friends we made along the way.